As a librarian, I was immediately concerned when I read news that vice presidential hopeful Sarah Palin once tried to censor library books during her tenure as mayor of Wasilla, Alaska. According to Time Magazine, Palin approached a local librarian, Mary Ellen Baker, and asked her how she would go about banning some books that voters found to contain inappropriate language (Read the entire article, Mary Palin: A Rough Record). In addition, a February 1, 1997 article in the Anchorage Daily News reports that Palin threatened to fire Mary Ellen Baker (listed in the article as Mary Ellen Emmons), saying ”I do not feel I have [her] full support in my efforts to govern the city of Wasilla.” This news arrived in a letter to both Mary Ellen Emmons, who served as Wasilla’s library director for seven years, and police chief Irl Stambaugh. Stambaugh was indeed fired, while Emmons was allowed to stay after further conversations with Palin.
This whole situation reminds me of the recent controversy in Oklahoma surrounding representative Sally Kern. In 2004, Kern supported withdrawing funding from public libraries that did not segregate children’s books dealing with homosexuality (like King and King) from the rest of the collection (Read an article from the Oklahoman on this issue). Thankfully, this measure did not pass.
Why do so many politicians continue to try and push their way into public libraries and infringe on our customers’ freedom to read? To all librarians out there, I say stay strong. Politicians bring their own agendas, and the library should not bend to their will. If you need a quick pick-me-up, dig out that graduate school copy of the Library Bill of Rights and give it another read. Or check out a book that I recently picked up for The Big Read, Fahrenheit 451. And if all else fails, why not read the American Library Association’s advice on fighting censorship?
It is our responsibility as librarians to protect our customers’ freedom to read from the special interest groups and the overzealous politicians.
Sep 4, 2008 at 11:39 am
Thank you for writing about this. To all the librarians out there I say-thank you for what you do and VOTE!
Sep 4, 2008 at 11:51 am
[...] http://bookdweeb.wordpress.com/2008/09/04/sarah-palin-banning-books-and-the-impact-on-public-librari... [...]
Sep 4, 2008 at 11:05 pm
Someone needs to track down Mary Ellen Emmons (Baker) and convince her to come forward and speak about Sarah Palin’s attempts to ban books. This sort of personal and arbitrary censorship is against everything this country stands for and violates the First amendment of the Constitution, a document that the Vice President will be required to swear to uphold under oath. This needs wider media attention and we need Mary Ellen to come forward about this.
Sep 5, 2008 at 2:34 am
Why haven’t I heard about this story from our so-called “left wing” media??? I agree with mlaiuppa – I wish Ms. Baker would come forward and discuss the books Palin wanted to ban.
Sep 6, 2008 at 5:27 am
Politicians address these issues not necessarily because they believe in their validity but because “morality” is a benchmark of any campaign. Censorship is a passive way to assure individuals that the government will protect them from things they fear or do not understand. Knowledge is power; but the acquisition of it is also hard work. It would be very easy to simply conclude that Governor Palin is narrow-minded and her policies are fueled by stereotypical motivations. I would much prefer to have the candidate speak for herself in 2008, rather than rely solely on information in 1997. Librarians by our very nature are researchers; we listen and formulate conclusions based on the evaluation of resources. Perhaps ALA can help clarify the true nature of Governor Palin’s attitudes towards intellectual freedom by insuring these questions are asked of all candidates at the upcoming debates.
Sep 6, 2008 at 11:50 pm
[...] http://bookdweeb.wordpress.com/2008/09/04/sarah-palin-banning-books-and-the-impact-on-public-librari... [...]
Sep 24, 2008 at 5:32 pm
Oh, how I agree with you. Book banning INFURIATES me, and I wanted to scream when I read about Palin’s nefarious attempts. I’ve passed around this info to some friends and will do what I can to inform others. This kind of behavior is unacceptable.